After 25 years of testing bird feeders and trying over 150 different models, I've finally compiled my definitive list of the best bird feeders you can buy in 2024. These aren't just theoretical recommendations – I've personally used each of these feeders in my own backyard for months.
The "best" feeder depends on which birds you want to attract. Cardinals prefer platform feeders, finches love tube feeders with small perches, and woodpeckers need suet feeders. I'll help you match the right feeder to your goals.
Quick Comparison: Top 5 at a Glance
| Feeder | Best For | Rating | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Squirrel Buster Plus | Squirrel Problems | ⭐ 4.9/5 | $67 |
| Droll Yankees A-6 | Finches & Small Birds | ⭐ 4.8/5 | $45 |
| Woodlink Platform | Cardinals & Jays | ⭐ 4.7/5 | $35 |
| Aspects HummZinger | Hummingbirds | ⭐ 4.9/5 | $25 |
| Birds Choice Suet | Woodpeckers | ⭐ 4.6/5 | $28 |
1. Best Overall: Squirrel Buster Plus
Squirrel Buster Plus Bird Feeder
- ✓ 100% Squirrel-proof
- ✓ Lifetime warranty
- ✓ Easy to clean
- ✓ Holds 3+ lbs seed
Affiliate link - I earn a small commission at no cost to you
The Squirrel Buster Plus has been my go-to recommendation for over a decade. It uses a weight-sensitive mechanism that closes the seed ports when anything heavier than a bird lands on it. I've watched squirrels try every trick in the book – they simply cannot defeat this feeder.
What I Love After 5 Years of Use
- Truly squirrel-proof: The weight-activated mechanism has never failed in my testing
- Incredibly durable: Mine has survived harsh winters, summer heat, and countless squirrel attacks
- Easy disassembly: Takes apart in seconds for cleaning without any tools
- Excellent capacity: Holds over 3 pounds of seed, reducing refill frequency
✓ Pros
- ✓ Lifetime warranty from Brome
- ✓ Completely squirrel-proof
- ✓ UV-stabilized components
- ✓ Dishwasher-safe parts
✗ Cons
- ✗ Higher price point
- ✗ Not ideal for large birds
- ✗ Weight mechanism needs occasional adjustment
2. Best for Finches: Droll Yankees A-6
Droll Yankees A-6 Tube Feeder
- ✓ Made in USA - Lifetime warranty
- ✓ Die-cast zinc top and base
- ✓ UV-stabilized polycarbonate tube
Droll Yankees has been making feeders since 1969, and the A-6 represents their decades of refinement. The heavy-duty metal components resist squirrel damage, while the crystal-clear tube lets you easily monitor seed levels.
3. Best Platform: Woodlink Going Green
Woodlink Going Green Platform Feeder
- ✓ Made from recycled plastic
- ✓ Drainage holes prevent water buildup
- ✓ Attracts cardinals, jays, and doves
Cardinals are notoriously picky about feeders. They need a stable platform with enough room for their long tails. This platform feeder is the best I've found for attracting these beautiful red birds.
4. Best Hummingbird: Aspects HummZinger Ultra
Aspects HummZinger Ultra
- ✓ Built-in ant moat
- ✓ Leak-proof design
- ✓ Easy to clean - dishwasher safe
- ✓ Raised flowers deter bees
I've tried dozens of hummingbird feeders, and the HummZinger consistently outperforms them all. The saucer design means no drips, and the built-in ant moat solves the #1 problem with hummingbird feeders.
5. Best Suet: Birds Choice Tail Prop
Birds Choice Tail Prop Suet Feeder
- ✓ Extended tail prop for woodpeckers
- ✓ Holds 2 suet cakes
- ✓ Made from recycled materials
🎨 Feeder Types: Which One Do You Need?
Know Your Feeder Types
Match the right feeder to the birds you want to attract
Hopper
House-shaped with seed reservoir. Great all-rounder.
Tube
Cylindrical with ports. Ideal for small birds.
Platform
Open tray design. Widest species variety.
Suet
Wire cage for suet cakes. Insect-eaters love it.
📅 Seasonal Bird Feeding Guide
When to Use Each Feeder Type
*Suet can melt in summer. Use no-melt suet cakes if temps exceed 80°F.
🔬 How I Test Bird Feeders
Every feeder on this list has been personally tested for at least 3 months. Here's my testing criteria:
Durability
Weather & squirrel resistance over 90+ days
Cleaning
Disassembly time & ease of washing
Attraction
Species count & daily visitors
Capacity
Seed volume & refill frequency
Value
Quality vs. price & long-term cost
- Durability: Can it withstand weather and squirrel attacks?
- Ease of cleaning: How long does it take to disassemble and clean?
- Bird attraction: How many species and individuals visit?
- Seed capacity: How often do I need to refill?
- Value: Is the quality worth the price?
🧹 Essential Feeder Maintenance Tips
Clean Every 2 Weeks
Soak in a 1:9 bleach-to-water solution. Rinse well and dry completely before refilling.
Check for Mold
Wet or clumped seed breeds bacteria. Discard any seed that looks discolored or smells off.
Rotate Seed Types
Mix sunflower, safflower, nyjer, and peanuts to attract a wider variety of species.
Position Wisely
Place feeders 10-12 ft from cover so birds can escape predators but squirrels can't jump.
Use Baffles
A pole baffle adds extra squirrel and raccoon protection even on squirrel-proof feeders.
Seasonal Adjustments
Add suet in winter for energy. Offer nectar in spring/summer for hummingbird migrants.
🎯 Not Sure Which Feeder is Right for You?
Take my 2-minute quiz to get a personalized recommendation based on your yard, budget, and bird goals.
Take the Feeder Quiz →❓ Frequently Asked Questions
What type of bird seed attracts the most species?
Black oil sunflower seed is the single best seed for attracting the widest variety of birds. It's high in fat, has a thin shell that small birds can crack easily, and is loved by cardinals, chickadees, finches, nuthatches, and many more.
How do I keep squirrels off my bird feeder?
The most effective solution is a weight-activated feeder like the Squirrel Buster Plus. You can also use pole-mounted baffles, place feeders 10+ feet from jumping surfaces, or try safflower seed which squirrels generally dislike but cardinals love.
How often should I clean my bird feeder?
Clean every two weeks minimum, or more often in warm, humid weather. Use 1 part vinegar to 9 parts hot water. Scrub thoroughly, rinse well, and let dry completely. Dirty feeders can spread diseases like salmonellosis.
Should I feed birds year-round?
Yes! Winter feeding provides critical energy when natural food is scarce. Spring and summer feeding helps parents raising chicks. Studies show birds with feeder access have higher survival rates and better breeding success.
Where is the best place to hang a bird feeder?
Place feeders in a quiet area with good visibility, 10-12 feet from trees or shrubs. Near a window for viewing but with decals to prevent strikes. Avoid direct afternoon sun in summer as seed spoils faster.
Do bird feeders attract unwanted animals?
They can. Use no-mess seed blends to reduce ground debris, bring feeders in at night if raccoons or bears are present, use caged feeders to exclude starlings, add baffles, and clean up spilled seed regularly.
🎁 Bonus: Best Smart Bird Feeder
Beako™ Smart Bird Feeder with Camera – 4K Video, AI Bird ID, Solar Panel
Final Thoughts
🏆 Our Top Pick
After 25 years of bird feeding, I can confidently say that investing in quality feeders pays off. A cheap $10 feeder might seem like a bargain, but you'll replace it within a year. The feeders on this list will serve you for decades.
My top pick for most people: The Squirrel Buster Plus remains undefeated. Yes, it costs more upfront, but the lifetime warranty and squirrel-proof performance make it the best long-term value.
Happy birding! 🐦
— Medhat Youssef, 25-Year Bird Enthusiast
Check Price on Amazon →
Sarah from Texas
just purchased Squirrel Buster Plus
2 minutes ago